Gal Gadot and Wonder Woman’s Tarnished Tiara

Okay. It’s time to drag out the old soapbox again. This one might actually cost me readers, but I feel strongly about this issue: Gal Gadot.

Some of the criticism she has been receiving lately—from her very portrayal of Wonder Woman, to her support for women in the “me too” movement, to her support for gun control—has been quite harsh. And all of the criticism seems to focus on one thing: the fact that she’s an Israeli Jew.

Perhaps my own perception is skewed; after all, I am, myself, Jewish. But I am getting tired of the barbs being levelled at Gal simply for her being who she is (Yes, that’s a slight oversimplification. Hear me out.).

Many will not accept her support for women, because as an Israeli, she oppresses Palestinian women. Many will not accept her stance on gun control in America, because as an Israeli, she’s a child murderer. Many will not accept her playing a character who stands for the downtrodden and disenfranchised, as Diana does, because as an Israeli, she’s an occupier, an oppressor, and a stealer of other people’s land. She is condemned because as an Israeli, she happens to support her own country’s military, and because she served, and served as a combat instructor. And now here’s what upsets me—

First off, everyone serves. There is mandatory service for all in Israel. So the fact that she served in the IDF means that she was a good citizen. She did not, after all, become a career soldier. This alone should not be drawing such opprobrium upon her.

Second, she publically supported the IDF during the operations in Gaza in 2014. Now, do I think that the Israeli response to Hamas might have been excessive? Sure. On the other hand, I do not live within the range of Qassam rockets, and I do not have to deal with infiltration of my own homeland. Yes, Israel is far more powerful than Hamas; but how many rockets and attempted terrorist acts are they expected to absorb? And Gal was correct in her noting that Hamas hides behind women and children as shields. They set up their launch sites in school courtyards, or on the roofs of hospitals, counting on this to protect them, relying on the civilized nature of their opponents. Is Israel expected to leave itself open and defenseless in the face of these tactics?

Now, all this said thus far, do I approve of Netanyahu’s government? Absolutely not. Do I approve of the Settler movement trying to grab up all the remaining Palestinian land, destroying olive groves and crops, and attacking their Palestinian neighbors? Absolutely not. Do I think that Israeli public opinion concerning the Palestinians is toxic? Absolutely it is. While I call myself a Zionist, I see no reason why we shouldn’t all be able to get along and share the land—my own concern is that it is the religious fringes on both sides preventing us from actually coming together and entering in upon a reasonable agreement.

But attacking Gadot as if she were somehow responsible for Israeli government policy is not fair. She’s a prominent figure, a celebrity, so yes; she’s an easy target. As Jews, throughout most of modern history, we have been hounded out of countries, hunted, slandered, vilified, and murdered, because of who we are. Gal’s grandparents were survivors of the Shoah; why wouldn’t she support a defense force that after so many centuries allowed us to stand up without fear amongst the nations? And why should it be wrong?

Here’s another thing—has anyone thought to ask if Gadot’s opinions on military policy have changed at all over the years? Or has anyone thought to ask her for clarification on her views? Is it not possible for a person’s attitudes and beliefs to evolve?

I have personal friends who have served in the Golani brigade. While they support their country, and their military, they do not all want to destroy the Palestinians. –In fact, one friend of mine came very close to beating the shit out of his CO during a tour in the West Bank, because he had dragged an old man out of his house and was humiliating him in front of his own family.

Yes, it is true that when you keep a large population under ward, it brutalizes the wardens as well as the prisoners. This is a mutual trap that we must escape.

But my whole point here is that judging Gal Gadot for simply loving her country, and doing her duty as a citizen is not fair. By all means, criticize government policy. Let’s have a debate on the occupation. But this criticism of Gadot for simply being an Israeli citizen is frightfully annoying to me. My own feelings about the relationship between Israel and Palestine can be read here.


About Michael Butchin

I was born, according to the official records, in the Year of the Ram, under the Element of Fire, when Johnson ruled the land with a heavy heart; in the Cradle of Liberty, to a family of bohemians. I studied Chinese language and literature at Rutgers University, New Brunswick. I spent some years in Taiwan teaching kindergarten during the day, and ESOL during the evenings. I currently work as a high school ESOL teacher, and am an unlikely martial artist. I have spent much of my life amongst actors, singers, movie stars, beautiful cultists, Taoist immortals, renegade monks, and at least one martial arts tzaddik. I currently reside in Beijing's Dongcheng district
This entry was posted in Soap Box. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Gal Gadot and Wonder Woman’s Tarnished Tiara

  1. elenapedigo says:

    Interesting post! And I can’t help but think that the tactic of criticizing women who speak out about political issues, especially women’s rights, because they’re Israeli/American/Russian/white/wealthy/straight/Christian/etc. is a subtle way of silencing them and delegitimizing them and feminism. Funny how an Israeli woman suddenly stopped being a representation of diversity and became too…something to represent women as soon she gained a platform to speak from.

    The issue of Israeli-Palestinian relations is a fraught one, but if everyone whose country had ever done anything objectionable is banned from ever speaking out about anything, there’s going to be a lot of silence.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Indeed. The silencing of women, whatever the excuse or tactics used, seems to be a common thread in history.

      If I might, would you like (another) free copy of the book? I took your specific criticisms on board when I did the rewrite. You needn’t do another review, but I would love to hear your opinion on the revisions, if you’d be willing.


  2. elenapedigo says:

    Hi Michael! I wanted to let you know that I just finished reading the new version of “Medousa.” I really enjoyed it–I think you made it even more compelling. I’ve posted an updated version of my review on Goodreads and Amazon and also on my blog:

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to elenapedigo Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.